Signs your small business website needs replacing, and what to do next
Most owners do not decide overnight to get a new website. They notice small problems that keep coming back. This checklist helps you tell a quick repair from a real replacement, using guidance from Google and the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO).
Do I need a new website for my business? A quick test
A tired website is not always a broken one. Some problems are quick fixes: a wrong phone number, an old photo, a dead link. Replacing the whole site makes sense when the problems are built into how it works.
Work through the signs below. One or two ticks usually means a repair. Ticks in several sections usually means it is time to think seriously about a new website for your business.
Sign 1: it is awkward to use on a phone
Google says it "uses the mobile version of a site's content, crawled with the smartphone agent, for indexing and ranking." In plain English, the phone version of your site is the one Google looks at first.
Open your website on your own phone, on mobile data, and try to do what a customer would do. Tick any that apply:
- You have to pinch and zoom to read the text.
- Buttons and links are too close together to tap.
- Your phone number is plain text, not a tap to call link.
- Pages or menus on the phone show less than on a computer.
- You cannot find your opening hours or how to get a quote within a few taps.
Google asks site owners to "make sure that your mobile site contains the same content as your desktop site." If your phone version is a cut-down copy, that is a design problem, not something a small patch cures.
Sign 2: it looks like an outdated website
An outdated website does not just look old. It makes a stranger wonder whether you are still trading. Tick any that apply:
- The design looks like it belongs to a different decade.
- The footer shows a copyright year from long ago.
- Photos are old, blurry or show a van, shopfront or team that has changed.
- It lists services you no longer offer, or misses the ones you now sell most.
- Prices, hours or staff names are wrong and nobody has the time to fix them.
Ask a friend who does not know your business to look at it for ten seconds. If they cannot say what you do and how to contact you, the site is not doing its job.
Sign 3: it is slow or not secure
Google says its ranking systems use Core Web Vitals, which measure how a page loads and responds. It also asks a simple question about every site: "Are your pages served in a secure fashion?"
- Pages take a long time to appear on mobile data.
- The address starts with http, not https, or your browser warns that the site is not secure.
- Images are huge and jump about while the page loads.
One honest note. Google says a good page experience "doesn't guarantee that your pages will rank at the top of Google Search results", and that chasing a perfect score just for SEO "may not be the best use of your time." Fix speed and security because customers notice, not to game a number.
Sign 4: you cannot change it without a fight
Your business changes all the time, and your website should keep up. Tick any that apply:
- A one-line change means chasing someone for days.
- The person who built it has moved on, and nobody knows who hosts it.
- You do not know who holds the logins, or when the domain renews.
- Updates break things, so everyone avoids touching it.
If this is you, the real fix is a site that someone looks after. At Avori, hosting and care means we host it, secure it, back it up and make your changes for you.
Sign 5: it does not bring in enquiries
A website exists to start conversations. Tick any that apply:
- You do not appear on Google even when someone searches your exact business name.
- Your name, address and phone number differ from your Google Business Profile.
- There is no obvious next step, such as call, request a quote or book.
- Nobody is sure the contact form still sends emails to the right place.
Some of these live on Google rather than on your site. Our guide on why your business is not showing on Google Maps covers the profile side, and our local SEO service helps with both.
Sign 6: the cookie banner does not follow the rules
This one catches many small sites. The ICO says you must "get the person's consent to store a cookie on their device" and that you "cannot set non-essential cookies on your website's homepage before the user has consented to them."
The ICO also says continuing to browse does not count as consent, and that people should be able to enable or disable non-essential cookies easily. Check these:
- Does your banner say "by using this site you agree"? That is not enough.
- Can a visitor refuse as easily as accept?
- Do you know which cookies your site sets, and why?
This is general information, not legal advice. If you are unsure, read the ICO's cookie guidance or ask your adviser.
If you replace it, what should you keep?
A redesign should not throw away what already works. Before anything changes, make a list of:
- Your domain and email. The website can change without either of them moving. If the domain is changing hands, read moving your domain without losing your email first.
- Your page addresses. If any have to change, Google recommends "server side permanent redirects from the old URLs to the new URLs" and suggests keeping them "for as long as possible, generally at least 1 year."
- Your Google Business Profile details. The new site should show exactly the same name, address and phone number.
- Anything customers love. Real photos, honest reviews you have permission to use, and the way you explain what you do.
What to do next
- Tick the lists above and note how many sections have ticks.
- Write down the three things you want the site to do, such as phone calls, quote requests or bookings.
- Find your domain and hosting details, or ask us to help you find them.
- See a working version before you commit to anything.
That last step is how Avori works. We are a website studio in Harrow, North West London, and we build bespoke websites for local businesses. We make a private working demo of your new site first, so you can try it on your own phone before you pay.
Not sure where you stand? Ask for a free website check and we will tell you in plain English what is holding your current site back. Or request a private demo and see what we would build. You can read about our website design service too.
Sources
Common questions.
If the problems are small, such as old photos or a wrong phone number, a refresh is enough. If the site is hard to use on a phone, hard to update, or built in a way that stops you fixing things, a replacement usually costs less in the long run than patching it again and again.
There is no fixed number of years. A website is due for replacement when it stops doing its job: it works badly on phones, it is slow or insecure, it is hard to update, or it no longer shows what your business does today.
It does not have to. Google recommends server side permanent redirects from the old page addresses to the new ones, and keeping them in place for as long as possible, generally at least a year. We plan this before the new site goes live.
Yes. We build a private working demo of your new website first. You can open it on your own phone, share it with a colleague and ask for changes before you decide anything.
No. We are based in Harrow, North West London, and we work with local businesses across London and the towns around it. If you are in or near Harrow, we can also talk through your website in person.
Ask for your private demo
Tell us about your business. We reply within one working day, and there is no obligation.